When I was attending the AASL Conference in St. Louis, Missouri. and had a chance to see the Independent Movie, The Librarians.

As luck would have it, the movie had a little delayed start/technical issue and thanks to some colleagues, I had appointments with various book companies that allowed me to obtain books to bring back to many different individuals in my own state of Delaware. For that- 100% grateful – and I wondered when I would be able to get a chance to see the film that had my friends and


also contained polarizing views, coming from many that do not understand what librarians and libraries do to represent democracy. Amanda Jones is one of the most optimistic, positive leaders and librarians I have ever met. She epitomizes what librarianship is, and how this can be passed down to youth to be librarians of tomorrow. This means being researchers, guides, mentors and community leaders in the future.
Carolyn Foote never waivered when we were revamping our policy on challenged material, and patiently gave me example after example to work into a policy. That is the type of librarian she is!
Yet, fate would present itself in timely fashion. In Washington D.C. – January 22nd, 2025, at the AFI Silver Theatre and Cultural Center – and guess what? I did not hesitate.
On a very cold night, but very warm in anticipation, I found my way from DE to D.C. and settled in. There is SO much I could say but I am so very proud of my friends who are and have been on the front line for so so long – and some basic tenets as you watch this film yourself.
The claim that pornography exists in the library and is curated by librarians to be in the library AND that librarians groom students in inappropriate ways – rubbish. If you have doubts, please be willing to talk about things that concern you – topics that concern you- and please talk to HUNDREDS of students that have experienced (thanks to a supportive school district) a school library that contains so many points of view; they can have the freedom to choose what they want – age and view appropriate – (the former exists IF you have a certified librarian to discern those topics) .
Individuals taking excerpts from books that offend them – and not taking in a whole context of a book- there is a huge difference and fits the argument for one side and not all sides.
If there are books in the library I do not like (there are plenty that do not interest me or that I like) – and yet – I have to respect the fact that others DO like those books – certainly not books that promote pornography – PLLLLLEASE – that offends me on a personal level (and professional) for the time I trained to be an Information Science graduate student- and that was, and never will be, part of the curriculum. I strive every day to be a resource for what patrons, of all ages, viewpoints, backgrounds need – that is what a librarian profession does if you look at the training librarians are required to work through.
Simply stated, parents always have and still do have more control of what they want their children to read – librarians never have and never will take that right away. That has never been the case in our history.
Book Burning in Tennessee- 2022. “According to Tyler Salinas, a photographer who was present at the bonfire, there was one counter-protester, who held up copies of Fahrenheit 451 and On the Origin of Species, and threw a book into the fire that he said was the Bible.”

It is far easier to state that books are deemed inappropriate without reading them, (REALLY reading them) without talking to individuals who are trained to choose books that fit a variety of individuals that can benefit from something else someone else might not. But having discussion is amazing – but pulling books without that discussion- is just pulling books without having a full picture without a discussion about concerns first- and yet- this makes sense to so many people- I am STILL scratching my head over this.
What is dangerous with book banning and asking African American books and selections to be pulled, asking the fire of God to consume others- I have to stand back and ask the reason why pertinent books that have something specific to say about history, a history that is showing it self to be a country that if you have a different view- then you are to be made an example of and pulled out of the public view, a view we know as democracy.
I think the hardest line to swallow was at the 33:42 of the Librarians. ” I Hate Librarians”. When I went to Tampa Bay’s AASL convention, in a period that book banning was at its height, I felt a little nervous about my safety with so much hatred being directed towards librarians. Yet, the work that librarians do, they are the firewalls of democracy and a reason so many people deserve to have the right to different viewpoints. I do know, from my training, age-appropriate material is part of being a librarian. It is disheartening to think others without that professional training think they do know better than the trained professionals, a trained profession we chose to support as a basis of what our country stands for.
What I have learned over the last five years is that leaving youth out of these conversations, leaving youth out of the issues that impact them and in their schools, leaving youth out of school libraries, it is easy to see this is the worst mistake any organization can make, I say this after seeing what youth can do when given a voice, when given countless opportunities to grow, when given just a chance. It is everything. So much happens out of a library, clubs, organizations, and community ideas that become a reality – if you have a school library. if you don’t, you never realize what you don’t have. Hence, librarians and libraries mean more than what you do not know.
There is so much to say and so much that is not said, and so much that is said without merit. Now, more than ever is the continual need for a realistic push back on more accurate depictions of what literacy is and what is means to our world today. Not politicized. Not censoring freedoms that have always been who we are as a country.
I am so very grateful for amazing students, individuals and institutions that realize there are so many different points of view and libraries have the opportunity to represent many points of view and allow for different interpretations. You might not agree with what all books have to say or what they say, I am a librarian, and I certainly do not connect with many age appropriate books in our library. However, what librarians are trained to do, to protect the many diverse viewpoints that individuals look for, representing diverse viewpoints, and representing all individuals- not just viewpoints – I find to my personal liking. In making many steps in the right direction thanks to youth being involved- they are now becoming citizens of the world and have a wider view of many diverse viewpoints.
I have learned over the last few years that divisiveness is the most popular movement in today’s world, but also have seen the lasting impacts on youth, and it has been anything but positive for them. I am grateful that there are individuals I know as friends, as represented in The Librarians, that push back when needed for everyone.
It was therapeutic to hear the audience that night, in the theatre, to some of the statements made in the film. While much of this film was threatening, devastating, and tragic, the greatest feeling was that of courage, hope, and perseverance. Heck, that is what a librarian is all about!




















































